I'm not sure if you got a different book than me, but the book that I
have has his mother emerged first, then his father. It was supposed
to be in the reverse order of their deaths. And Harry's father was
killed first.

Hope that this clears up any confusion.

--- In gobletoffire2@yahoogroups.com, "alisajjadrathore"
<alisajjadrathore@y...> wrote:
> Hi, i have just joined this group. i wanted to clear a confusion.
In
> the book goblet of fire, the emergence of dead people from the
locked
> together wands was Cedric, Frank the gardner etc...... and then
> harry's father and his mother i.e, in the opposite order of their
> deaths.
>
> But in the 1st movie and in the Chamber of secrets as well, it is
> quite claer that Harry's father died first and then Voldemort
killed
> him mom. So whats with this contradiction in goblet of fire ? or
have
> i read some tainted version of the book ?
>
> Any one to clear this confusion ?